Redesign or start over? How to decide
2 min read Nikos Koulouridis
Your website looks tired. Do you refresh what's there or build a new one? A few honest questions make the choice much easier.
At some point every website starts to feel old. The colours look dated, it's awkward on a phone, or it simply doesn't say what your business does anymore. Then comes the question: fix what's there, or start again?
There's no single right answer, but there are a few questions that point clearly one way or the other.
1. Does it work well on a phone?
Most visitors arrive on a phone. If the site is hard to read, slow, or needs zooming on a phone, and it was built before that was normal, a fresh start is usually simpler than patching every page.
2. Can you still change it yourself?
If updating a price or a photo means emailing someone, or logging into something nobody remembers, that's a problem a redesign alone won't fix. If the editing side works fine and only the look is tired, a refresh may be enough.
3. Is the content still right?
Often the real issue isn't the design but the words: services you no longer offer, old photos, a description of the business from five years ago. Rewriting content is part of either option, and sometimes it's most of the work.
4. What's under the hood?
An old site on outdated software, with plugins that no longer get updates, is a security and speed risk. Fixing that piece by piece can cost more than rebuilding on something current.
5. What does Google already like?
If some pages bring you visitors from Google today, that's worth protecting. Whichever way you go, those pages should keep their content, and their old addresses should point to the new ones, so you don't lose what you've built up.
A quick rule of thumb
- Refresh when the structure works, it's fine on phones and easy to edit, and mainly the look and content feel old.
- Start over when it's poor on phones, hard to edit, built on old software, or no longer matches what your business does.
If you're unsure, send me the address. I'll look at it and tell you which way I'd lean, and why.
Want me to build it for you?